Beautiful, the question I want you asking this week


A question came up in our Vitality Conversation this week, and it is one I hear in the clinic almost weekly.

"What do I do if I have 5 kg to lose?"

Here is what I would like to offer you in response.

I do not want you asking that question anymore.

The kilo count is the wrong measure; it is a number that tells you almost nothing about what is actually happening inside your unique biochemistry.

The question I want you asking instead is, am I metabolically flexible?

Before I unpack that with you, I want to name the lens we have been working through this week.

The framework holding all of this together is the biopsychosocial model.

Your health is not just biology; it is biology in conversation with your psychology and with the social environment you are living inside.

A body in a war zone does not heal like a body in a beautifully supported community.

So as you read what follows, hold it in three layers:

  • what is happening biochemically,
  • what is happening in your thoughts and your nervous system, and
  • what is happening around you.

All of it counts.

The reframe: from weight loss to metabolic flexibility

Metabolic flexibility is your body's ability to switch between burning glucose for fuel and burning fat for fuel.

When you can do both with ease, your energy is steady through the afternoon, your brain is sharp, your sleep deepens, and body composition begins to redistribute without you needing to fight for it.

When you cannot, you sit in a fat-store state most of the day; insulin runs high, cortisol misbehaves, and the long arc of that pattern is exactly where insulin resistance, type two diabetes, and the rising risk of Alzheimer's begin to sit.

Body composition is what I want you tracking, not the number on the scale.

There is also a perimenopause-specific reason the middle thickens for so many of us.

As progesterone begins to decline, a relative androgen excess sets in; that hormonal shift is one of the drivers of the band of softness many women notice just below the belly button.

(Just as an aside, if it's not the androgens, it's cortisol.)

It is not a moral failing or a lack of discipline; it is biochemistry, and it responds beautifully when we work in the right order.

Clinical note: a woman who is the same weight today as last year, but has lost lean mass and gained visceral fat, is in a worse metabolic position than a woman who has gained two kilos of muscle.

Composition matters; the scale lies.

Before any of this, we test

Before you change a single thing, I want you to measure your hip-to-waist ratio.

You will find the instructions inside the Vitality Clinic platform, under Tests.

It takes about ninety seconds and gives you a baseline you can return to; the result tells me far more about your metabolic risk than any number on a scale ever will.

Clinical note: hip-to-waist ratio is one of the strongest predictors of cardiovascular risk we have.

Insurers know this.

Your body knows this.

We measure first, then we work.

The gut is the gateway

If your gastrointestinal tract is inflamed, you cannot become metabolically flexible.

You can do every other thing right and still find yourself stuck.

Here is the mechanism, in plain language.

When you eat a food that does not work for you (and almost every woman has at least one or two of these), the lining of the gut becomes more permeable.

Bacterial endotoxins, called lipopolysaccharides or LPS, then move from the gut into the bloodstream; this is endotoxemia, and it drives a low-grade inflammatory state that the body responds to by holding fat, particularly around the middle.

The work is to remove the triggers, repair the lining, and reintroduce foods carefully so you can identify the few that are not serving you.

This is the Heal, Seal, and Repair Protocol: four weeks of an ideal foods list, followed by a structured reintroduction.

It is a tool, not a way of life.

The point is food freedom on the other side, not a new set of rules to obey.

I want to address something head-on, because it came up in our conversation, and I know it lives quietly in many of you.

If you carry a history of disordered eating, of restrictive dieting, of being weighed and shamed and told you were either good or bad based on what you ate, your nervous system will read this protocol as another deprivation.

It is not.

Print the ideal foods list.

Take it shopping with you.

Eat as much from it as you like.

There is no calorie counting and no portion control beyond a simple formula:

  • three cups of green,
  • one cup of colour, and
  • a palm-sized or hand-sized piece of high-quality protein at each meal,

three times a day.

Try to over-eat broccoli and steak; you will not be able to.

The work here is to turn the volume down on food noise, not turn it up.

The recipe book inside the platform has been built around exactly this.

There are soups, fritters, stir-fries, and a section of crunches that are both savoury and sweet.

There are protein balls, peanut chocolate bark, and a homemade Snickers bar that will surprise you.

You are not removing joy or pleasure from your food; you are establishing your own n-of-1 individualised food protocol so that nobody, ever again, gets to tell you what to eat.

Take a Sunday, put the music on, walk the recipe book front to back, choose what excites you, and shop for it.

Make it a ceremony.

Bring your partner along; the work is so much easier when you are not eating differently from the person sleeping next to you.

A woman in our clinic shared this week that she was carrying so much anxiety around starting The Heal, Seal, and Repair, because of how restriction had landed on her body in earlier seasons of her life.

Another woman a few weeks ahead of her on the same path shared what had worked for her:

  • a slow on-ramp,
  • no rip-the-bandaid moment,
  • just gentle replacement of foods one at a time,
  • eating freely from the ideal foods list.

She told the circle that within a fortnight she felt remarkably better, and that her motivation to keep going came from the body itself, not from willpower.

That is the work, Reader.

Borrow her enthusiasm until you can feel your own.

Clinical note: lean on the recipe book inside the platform.

The soups, the fritters, the stir-fries, and the crunchy treats are designed to keep you nourished and out of deprivation.

Cortisol, stress, and why the gut is listening

Stress raises cortisol, and cortisol raises gut permeability.

The more permeable your gut becomes, the more systemic inflammation circulates in the body; that inflammation drives insulin up and stalls fat burning.

That is the cascade, and fighting for radical peace in your daily life is not soft work; it is metabolic work.

There is a sleep dimension to this that you need to know about.

Many of us in perimenopause find ourselves wide awake between 1 and 3 am.

That waking is most often a cortisol spike, and the cortisol spike is usually triggered by a small drop in blood glucose overnight.

The brain reads the drop as a threat, cortisol rises to push glucose back up, and you are suddenly awake and unable to settle.

A simple way to interrupt that cascade is a small protein-fat snack just before bed: three macadamia nuts, or a teaspoon of nut butter, taken about ten minutes before lights out.

It is enough to stabilise blood glucose through the night and keep cortisol quiet.

Clinical note: a woman in chronic sympathetic dominance does not lose weight, no matter how clean her food is.

The nervous system has to come down before the metabolism will move.

Blood glucose, not ketones

A question came up about whether to track ketones. My answer, after twenty-six years of clinical practice, is no.

Track blood glucose instead.

Insulin resistance is the central problem in perimenopausal weight gain; ketones are downstream of that.

Blood glucose monitoring tells you, in real time how your body is responding to:

  • your food,
  • your sleep,
  • your stress,
  • your morning cortisol awakening response, and
  • your training.

It is the most useful piece of body literacy data you can collect in this season.

The number I want you working towards, in a fasted state, is between 3.9 and 4.9 mmol/L.

That range is where fat burning happens. If you sit consistently above it, we have work to do; if you can hold it for most of the day, your metabolism is doing its job.

If you want a tool that supports this work, the Power Cuppa is built for it.

Twelve grams of high-quality collagen, a teaspoon of MCT oil powder, and a serving of GI Restore in your morning drink gives the body just enough protein, fat, and fibre to count as supported fasting; it is not a full meal, so the body stays in fat-burning mode, and the brain receives the exogenous ketones from the MCT and switches on.

That is the experience women describe as the lights coming on in the first hour of the day.

It is not magic; it is fuel.

There is also a circadian piece worth knowing.

Once the sun sets, the body becomes more insulin resistant; the same plate of food eaten at six in the evening will land very differently to the same plate eaten at nine.

So as much as you can, eat in daylight hours, and finish your last meal early.

Your blood glucose will thank you, and your sleep will too.

Clinical note: a continuous glucose monitor for two weeks teaches a woman more about her own body than ten years of dieting. Use it as a tool, not a verdict.

There is no universal macro ratio

I am not going to tell you to eat 30/40/30, or to count grams, or to follow anyone's protocol named for someone else.

There is no universal ratio of protein to fat to carbohydrate that works across all women, all phases of cycle, all biochemistries.

What works for you in luteal will not be what works for you in follicular; the ratio that suits you at thirty-eight may not be the one that suits you at fifty-two.

The seasons matter too.

This is why we begin with Heal, Seal, and Repair, and then we build your personal protocol from the ground up.

An experiment of one, Reader.
That is how this is done.

If your bleed is heavy, we measure it

A question landed this week about what counts as a heavy menstrual bleed.

The answer is anything over 80 ml across the whole cycle.

Inside the platform, under Tests, you will find the menstrual blood loss assessment; please use it.

We measure first, then we work upstream to find the root cause.

Clinical note: a single cycle above 80 ml is not a problem; six cycles in a row will deplete your iron, your energy, and your thyroid function in that order.

Movement that you love, or none at all

If you do not enjoy your movement, you will not do it.

So I want you choosing modalities you actually like: walking, cycling, swimming, yoga, Pilates, dancing in your kitchen with the dog underfoot.

Pick what makes you feel good.

Do not elastic-band back to whatever you used to do at twenty-five.

The body you have now is not that body, and it is not meant to be.

Strength matters in perimenopause, and it matters greatly; bone density and lean mass are non-negotiable for the next forty years of your life.

But strength does not require a barbell or a bro-gym.

  • Bodyweight squats,
  • deadlifts done with a kettlebell at home,
  • resistance bands,
  • a Pilates reformer, or
  • a well-supervised exercise physiologist

will all build you the muscle you need.

I want you on a slow on-ramp.

Forty minutes of walking, five days a week, is a beautiful place to begin.

Layer Pilates or strength work in once you feel the energy build, not before.

And if a session leaves you needing an afternoon nap to recover, you went too hard; pull back, and let the body catch up.

Never exercise to exhaustion in this season.

The dominant narrative right now says women must lift heavy, and I am not arguing against strength work.

I am arguing against jumping in at a load your nervous system cannot recover from.

The slow on-ramp is the same principle as the ideal foods list. It is the kindest, most sustainable way in.

Clinical note: in perimenopause, sleep is the first priority and movement is the second.

Never sacrifice one for the other.

This week's key takeaways

  1. The question is not "what do I weigh"; it is "am I metabolically flexible?"
  2. Measure your hip-to-waist ratio inside the platform under Tests, before you change anything else.
  3. The gut is the gateway. Heal, Seal, and Repair is a four-week tool, not a life sentence. Print the ideal foods list and use it as your shopping list.
  4. Three cups of green, one cup of colour, and a palm-sized piece of protein, three times a day. Eat as much as you like.
  5. Blood glucose between 3.9 and 4.9 mmol/L is the fat-burning range. Track that, not ketones.
  6. A protein-fat snack before bed (three macadamias, or a teaspoon of nut butter) helps prevent the 1 to 3 am cortisol waking.
  7. A heavy bleed is anything over 80 ml across the whole cycle; measure first, then work upstream.
  8. Move in ways you love, on a slow on-ramp. Sleep first, movement second.

Your action this week

Go into the Vitality Clinic platform and complete two assessments under Tests: the hip-to-waist ratio measurement, and (if relevant for you) the menstrual blood loss assessment.

(if you'd like to try out if The Vitality Clinic is right for you, click here. Easy to join. Easy to leave if it's not your vibe.)

These are the foundation of everything else we will build together.

This is the work, Reader.

We start by turning the volume down on the food noise, and from there we build outwards: hip-to-waist measurement, gut repair, blood glucose tracking, and movement that you actually love.

None of it is fast; all of it sustains.

You are building body literacy, not chasing a number.

You are building food freedom, not a new diet to fail at.

And you are doing it inside a structured system that I have spent twenty-six years putting together for you.

Hold the biopsychosocial frame as you go.

Notice the biology, yes; notice also what your thoughts are doing, what your nervous system is asking for, and what your environment is making easy or hard.

Healing is never linear, and it is never only chemical.

I will see you in our next call.

Until then, walk gently with this; you are becoming your most vital, vibrant self, and the body knows what to do once we stop interrupting it.

Warmly,

Dr Kirstey Holland x


Dr Kirstey Holland
Doctor of Traditional Chinese Medicine / Practitioner of Environmental & Nutritional Medicine
Functional Medicine Practitioner (using precision functional testing) / Trauma Informed Health Mentor
THE HOLLAND CLINIC

The Holland Clinic

Dr Kirstey Holland is the Founder of The Holland Clinic. Helping women in perimenopause restore energy, clarity, metabolic balance, and a deep sense of vitality—so they can feel like themselves again, and function at a high level. Through a structured, doctor-led approach, women are guided through the Hierarchy of Healing—a process developed over 26 years of clinical practice that addresses gut health, hormones, metabolism, and the nervous system in the right order. This work is brought to life through the Holland Clinic Protocol: Eat, Sleep, Move, Think, Connect, Test, Prescribe. Author of This Is Perimenopause.

Read more from The Holland Clinic

Hello, There is something I see often in my clinic. A woman has gone several months without a period, decides she must now be menopausal, and accepts a treatment created for menopausal women. Her bleeding gets heavier, her breasts get tender, her sleep gets worse, and she wonders what she is doing wrong. She is doing nothing wrong. Until twelve months and one day have passed without a bleed, her ovaries are still active and she is still perimenopausal, which is almost the opposite hormonal...

Hi beautiful, A woman came to see me a few years ago, and on paper there was very little wrong. Her gut had settled, she was sleeping more than she had in months, and by every physical measure she should have been feeling better. She sat across from me and told me she felt heavy, like she was moving through water. We had repaired a great deal of the biology and something was still unwell, and it was not bacterial, it was not a deficiency, and I could not put a pathology form on it. That is...

Hello beautiful, We tend to think of bone loss as a menopause problem, something to worry about later. The evidence suggests it often begins earlier, in the years when ovulation becomes less reliable and progesterone, the hormone that builds new bone, starts to fall. That is the part so many women are never told. You can have a regular-looking period and still not be ovulating every month, and from your mid-thirties that becomes more common. So the bone-building side of the equation can...